Blue Dogs Bite the Hand that Feeds Them

Recently there has been a swarm of press surrounding the issue of health insurance reform. This issue is the subject of one of the most contentious debates this decade, attracting hordes of voters (both for and against) to town-hall meetings and other events. Republicans seem stubbornly opposed to any reform of any type, despite their public statements that they wish to compromise. Throughout this debate, Blue Dog Democrats have been trying to put the brakes on reform in various ways, trying to please both conservative and progressive voters in their home districts. While a number of these votes are not important, we cannot afford to lose many more.

In a recent article from, it was announced that 23 Democrats have said that they will vote no on health care reform. Some are definitive answers; others seem willing to move on the issue. Still, this is the same type of thing that we have seen from Democrats in the past on this very same issue. They simply do not seem to be able to hold the party together well enough to be able to pass sweeping legislation. They simply do not possess the lock-step mentality of the Republicans, and this hampers them immensely.

The conservative Democrats who block reform have got to be there for their people on this issue. I understand that those who live in conservative or highly contested districts must deal with the realities of their post. They must, above all else, maintain their roles as representatives lest they lose their seats to Republicans. In order to have any effect at all they must maintain the position.

However, it is a problem comes when a Democrat panders too much to their conservative voters. Quite frankly, if a Democrat cannot even vote yes on a staggeringly important bill which we may not have another chance to pass for another century, then they have no business in that party. If they cannot support a bill like this, when they are needed the most, then we may as well cede that seat to a Republican. We may as well because those Republicans will then have to play defensive toward the progressives in their district, and thus annoy their own caucus. Though our current majorities in both chambers may be nice numerically, these sorts of “Democrats” aren't helping anyone by deceiving their constituencies.

I do not feel that it is unreasonable to ask that these Blue Dog and conservative Democrats straighten up. To do this, their constituents will have to hold them accountable. We, as voters, cannot be taken in by them as they talk through both sides of their mouth. Yes, it sounds reasonable to delay a vote for a few more months – but this is just another delay tactic to wait until reform is impossible. Yes, they want to include conservative ideas in the bill – but only to cover their own backsides (rather than a sense of bipartisanship).. Yes, they may even claim that many in their districts do not support this bill. But when it comes down to it these Congressmen and women know that this is the right thing to do. We must see their double-speak for what it is – just another attempt to get re-elected. We must tell them what they need to hear – that if they stand a chance at re-election then they had better listen to us. We are the people they were elected to represent – the quiet majority. True, we may not scream at them now, as do their conservative constituents. But they need to know that if they fail to act, they will be made to remember us on election day.

Andrew S. Bailey, MSW
Co-chair, Missouri Association for Social Welfare, Western division


Thank you! I have been so frustrated over the past several years with conservative Democrats (and, truly, moderate Republicans) whose votes are quite appalling but who then try to excuse them by talking about their likely election opposition and how certain votes would make them vulnerable. I have always asked why in the world I should care if they lose to a more conservative opponent if, in order to protect themselves, they're going to vote that way anyway? We need to get over our 'at least it's not...' mentality and hold our "friends" at least as accountable as those more naturally opposed to our values.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6><img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.

HCF's Local Health Buzz Blog aims to discuss health and health policy issues that impact the uninsured and underserved in our service area. To submit a blog, please contact HCF Communications Officers, Jennifer Sykes, at